Public vs Private Colleges and Universities
When choosing a college or university, a key element of the decision will be whether to attend a public or private institution. Many believe that avoiding the higher-priced private universities will make thier education more affordable. But that’s not necessarily the case.
My daughter was accepted to several public universities in the state of Texas, where she lived. They offered nothing in their financial aid package, but their cost of attendance was significantly lower than the private colleges and universities she applied to.
However, the private colleges offered substantial financial aid, making their offers more attractive and affordable.
If you wonder which choice is best for you, here are some comparisons that should help you make an informed decision about private vs. public colleges.
What is a public university?
Public universities have their tuition and fees subsidized by local, state and federal governments. This funding supports a significant portion of their operational costs, allowing these institutions to offer lower tuition rates to in-state students.
Out-of-state students, however, will usually pay a higher cost for the same education. These colleges also typically have larger student bodies.
What is a private college or university?
Private colleges and universities rely heavily on tuition and fees, private donations, endowments, and other private funding sources. They are independently operated and often have more flexibility in how they are governed and their curriculum development.
The lack of state funding means that they need to generate sufficient revenue through the tuition they receive and their fundraising efforts to operate.
What are the key differences between the two?
The fundamental differences between public and private universities are tuition and financial aid, campus culture and diversity, class size and faculty interaction, and opportunities and resources.
We’ll dive into these now.
Tuition and financial aid
Public schools
Public schools tend to be less expensive because the government funds they receive help to subsidize costs, including tuition.
State schools were created to educate the residents of that state. They could offer in-state student financial aid options for in-state students or students who attended high school in the state.
Private schools
Private schools tend to have higher advertised tuition rates, but they can sometimes be just as affordable. They offer tailored financial aid packages created for students because of generous alumni support and donations.
Because of that, private colleges generally have more money to distribute to admitted students in the form of grants and scholarships. Students then may also recieve federal financial aid.
If a private college or university is on your list, don’t discount it purely on the initial sticker price. Check out the net price calculators hosted on college websites to help you determine how much financial aid you may expect to receive from the institution.
Campus culture and diversity
Public schools
Public universities tend to have larger student populations, leading to a more diverse campus culture. The larger size institutions often offer students a more comprehensive selection of extracurricular activities, clubs, and organizations.
Students may experience a vibrant and dynamic social scene, with opportunities to engage in a variety of interests and activities.
Private schools
Private schools typically have smaller student bodies, which can result in a more close-knit and intimate campus community. The smaller size can foster stronger connections between students and faculty, as well as among the student body.
Additionally, the overall environment might be more tailored to specific interests or values that align with the school's mission, such as a religious preference or a commitment to supporting climate change.
Class size and faculty interaction
Public schools
Public universities often have larger class sizes, particularly in introductory courses. Most of my son’s first-year courses at a public university consisted of classes in large auditoriums with hundreds of students.
This high student-to-faculty ratio can lead to less personalized attention from your professors. Many classes may be taught by teacher assistants or adjunct professors.
Private schools
Class sizes at private universities are generally smaller, giving students more direct interaction with faculty. This can greatly enhance the learning experience through personalized instruction, mentoring, and opportunities for collaboration.
My daughter had relationships with her professors at a private college, and they helped her gain employment after graduation. Smaller classes also encourage more active participation and engagement from students.
Available opportunities and resources
Public schools
Thanks to their government funding, public universities tend to have better infrastructure. This includes more innovative labs, research facilities, and massive libraries.
If you are interested in a career in scientific research, you will find the best resources at a public university. They may also have a strong alumni network and industry connections, offering more internships and job placement opportunities. In addition, they offer a wide range of graduate and doctoral programs.
Private schools
By contrast, most private colleges have few research facilities and student resources. They also offer fewer academic programs and majors than public universities.
There are a few exceptions, like Cornell or Johns Hopkins, which are well endowed by private donors. However, most small private colleges simply cannot compete with the research efforts and facilities of public universities.
The flip side is that they have strong alumni networks that students can leverage to find internships and career opportunities.
Decision points for comparing public vs private schools
When it comes right down to it, the choice will be different for every student. It will depend on your own academic aspirations and personal needs. When deciding, work through these decision points.
The overall cost of your education
When considering a public versus private college, remember to factor in the cost of attendance. Cost should always be an important factor in your decision, but it should also align with your objectives.
A private college may have a higher price tag but offer substantial scholarships and grants to make it affordable. A public university may be cheaper but if it doesn’t fit your academic goals, you might want to look elsewhere.
Your college choice is also an investment. You should evaluate whether the cost of the degree will provide you with significant income after graduation.
The Georgetown Center on Education and the Workforce released a report titled “A First Try at ROI: Ranking 4,500 Colleges.” The report ranked 4,500 colleges and universities (both private and public) based on their return on investment.
They found that private universities in the US offer a higher ROI than public universities 40 years after enrollment.
The major you are pursuing
Students at a public university may have a wider choice in the courses, majors, minors, and degrees they can pursue. A liberal arts major and a student pursuing a more specialized degree will both be accommodated at a public university.
Most public colleges, especially the larger ones, have something to offer everyone. Whether it’s a general liberal arts major you’d like to pursue or something more specialized, most public colleges have something to offer everyone.
Private colleges are ideal for students with a liberal arts or scholarly focus. A large public university may offer upwards of 200 majors, while a small private college could offer as few as 30.
Again, the trade-off is that the smaller scale and scope of many private colleges offer more opportunities for one-on-one mentoring from a faculty advisor or professor.
Consider the learning environment you prefer
If you are an independent learner and require little academic assistance, a public university might be a good fit. Larger classes and more students mean less help and guidance from the professors.
Help is available, but you will be responsible for seeking assistance and reaching out.
On the other hand, private colleges are more suited for students who would like a more personal learning environment. The small class size gives students a chance to develop close relationships with their professors and academic advisors.
As a result, at private colleges, students usually get more direct assistance and guidance.
The campus culture
Public universities have a large student body, which means more campus activities and student clubs, often including a large Greek population. If you crave a campus with more options and choices or are looking for a college with a strong athletic program or Greek life, a public university could be a good fit.
However, campus life at private colleges can be just as active. Although smaller in size and scale, campus life at private colleges can be just as thriving and vibrant. Private colleges do tend to have a tight, close-knit community, making it easier to find your niche.
Investigate each school individually
Take the public versus private college conversation out of the equation. Does a prospective college meet most of your needs academically, financially, and socially?
Just because a school is public doesn’t mean you’ll be overlooked. Likewise, just because a private school is smaller in size doesn’t mean it’s lacking in resources.
Before applying, tour the campus, meet with academic advisors, and connect with current students and alumni to decide if it’s a good fit for you.
Wrapping up the public vs. private comparison
Choosing between private and public colleges hinges on many factors unique to your needs and aspirations. Public colleges often offer a more affordable education with a diverse campus experience and a broad range of programs. On the other hand, private colleges tend to provide smaller class sizes, more personalized attention, and specialized programs, usually at a higher cost.
As a prospective student, you should consider your own financial situation, academic goals, desired campus culture, and career aspirations when making this critical decision. By doing your own research and visiting the campuses, you can select the college or university that best aligns with your personal and career objectives, giving you the confidence to choose wisely.
Know where you stand when you apply to college
As you begin to consider college options, it's helpful to know where you stand and how competitive you'll be when you submit applications.
Create a free Appily account, and you can use your academic information—GPA and test scores—to estimate your likelihood of being admitted to the schools on your list.
Knowing your chances of admission before you apply will save you time, money, and stress. Just click the button below to get started.
